Hailing from Minneapolis and variously described as playing a form of spooky-synth and goth-rock, Graveyard Club – made up of lead singer Matthew Shufman (vocals, synths), Amanda Zimmerman (bass, vocals), Michael Wojtalewicz (guitar) and Cory Jacobs (drums) – have released three studio albums in the six years they have been together.
Brought together by a shared love of fifties melodies and alternative eighties bands such as The Cure, Echo & The Bunnymen, Joy Division and The Pixies, it’s not difficult to hear these strong influences in the Graveyard Club’s style, which incorporates more than a smattering of electro synth, melodic basslines and an air of melancholy desperation in Shufman’s distinct vocals. “When I was really young,” says Shufman, “I had a Best of the ‘80s album. It was pink with polka dots on it. It was the best album ever!”
Their debut album, Nightingale, which was released in 2014, premiered what have become some of the band’s trademarks: catchy, repetitive chorus lyrics and phrases, some precise vocal harmonies (‘Stay Young’), a soaring desperation in Shufman’s voice (‘Into The Dark’) and a curious juxtaposition of slower ballads and melancholic upbeat songs (‘The Night Is Mine’).
“When I was really young, I had a Best of the ‘80s album. It was pink with polka dots on it. It was the best album ever!”
Their second album, Cellar Door, was subsequently released in 2016 with an overall spookier and more downbeat feel than its predecessor, incorporating more of a horror/circus theme, fuzzy vocals and electro synth. It was followed in summer 2019 by Goodnight Paradise, which was an evolution from the sound of their previous albums, resulting in a very polished record produced by renowned producer, Andy Thompson (Belle & Sebastian, Taylor Swift). Still conveying a somewhat downbeat feel, Goodnight Paradise has a more multi-layered texture, with easier-sounding harmonies and perhaps a little more experimentation (in particular the vocals on ‘Maureen,’ a sense of Americana in ‘Cassandra’ and the hip-hop feel of ‘July’).
“Our sound has evolved,” explains Shufman. “We’re refining our sound and getting better. We’re not trying to replicate [the previous two albums], but it’s not a departure either.” Feedback from others was important in putting the album together, as well as collectively becoming interested in different sounds and using their new producer to make some key decisions. “He gets our sound,” says Wojtalewicz. “He feels like a true collaborator, which is impressive, as we’re not really collaborators!”
The two W songs of Goodnight Paradise – ‘William’ and ‘Witchcraft’ – are huge tracks, with a strong electro presence, and latest single ‘Valens’ is up-tempo with a great rhythm, while the title track, ‘Goodnight Paradise,’ and ‘Miles and Miles,’ convey a far slower and emotive sound.
“Our sound has evolved. We’re refining our sound and getting better. We’re not trying to replicate, but it’s not a departure either.”
However, the band have recently shifted focus back to their second album, which was originally only released on streaming services and CD but not in 12” format, which is something they were keen to rectify. Its recent re-release on limited edition opaque aqua vinyl at Hallowe’en, which also includes their excellent subsequent standalone single, ‘Ouija,’ appears to have been very well-received by their fans.
Wojtalewicz describes Cellar Door as a ‘turning point’ that earned the band a lot of new fans, with their personal standout tracks from the album being the title track, which felt ‘immediately noteworthy’ when they wrote it using the hip-hop drum feel, the general textures and its production, as well as ‘Nightcrawler’ and ‘Blue Angel,’ which have become consistently included in their live sets. With the four band members becoming vinyl nerds, it felt like an obvious choice for them to release it on vinyl, and they’ve been blown away with the fan response they’ve had so far. “It’s very touching to see how eager people are to support artists during this pandemic.”
“The silver lining with live music being shut down is that we can devote more of our attention to writing new music, which is always a huge undertaking.”
“I’m also really proud of how the final two songs, ‘Lose My Vision’ and ‘Werewolf Teeth,’ transition into each other and wrap up the record with a massive emotional and dynamic intensity,” adds Wojtalewicz, who explains those particular tracks can be really fun to play live, “where we can just let rip!”
Of course, the world is in a very different place now compared with when Cellar Door was originally released and from when Goodnight Paradise was released last year. Although the four acknowledge they are all fortunate to have day jobs, with weddings, engagements and new pets all adding to their lives since the start of the year, and – most importantly – that they are all healthy and generally staying afloat in these trying times, COVID has cancelled or postponed their shows for the last several months, as it has for other bands, which has been frustrating.
“The silver lining with live music being shut down is that we can devote more of our attention to writing new music, which is always a huge undertaking,” says Wojtalewicz. “With so much of the world sort of on pause, it takes certain pressures off us, and allows us to indulge in the behind-the-scenes creative process a little more than we might otherwise be able to.”
“I’m also really proud of how the final two songs, ‘Lose My Vision’ and ‘Werewolf Teeth,’ transition into each other and wrap up the record with a massive emotional and dynamic intensity.”
It has also given them an opportunity to take in other music and art forms which have inspired them during 2020, including the new Fontaines D.C. album and releases from Bright Eyes, The Strokes, Run the Jewels, Angel Olsen and Fleet Foxes. The four of them have also bonded more over their love of comedy, such as never-ending re-watching of The Office and the American comedy, PEN15.
Graveyard Club are proud that they’ve kept their music true to a cohesive vision over the years and yet they’ve also managed to refine and evolve their sound. Their biggest change is perhaps their process, which has gone from being in a rehearsal space, crafting songs around what they could play live and holing up in a studio for a few days. “That was fine,” explains Wojtalewicz, “but it was a bit limiting for what we wanted to achieve.” The result is that they now have the luxury of spreading out studio time and using it as a more creative space to bring demos to life with no deadlines or rules, doing what inspires them and sorting out the logistics later.
“It’s led to a lot more multi-tasking during live sets: using sequencers, triggering samples, mixing acoustic and electronic drums, ever-growing pedalboards, alternate guitar tunings, extra synths, more vocal interplay between Matt and Amanda’s vocals, etc. It provides a fun challenge!”
“With so much of the world sort of on pause, it takes certain pressures off us, and allows us to indulge in the behind-the-scenes creative process a little more than we might otherwise be able to.”
Although a new album was potentially in the pipeline for release in 2021, this has been delayed for obvious reasons. “We have been recording new music little by little, sometimes remotely, and sometimes by physically going into the studio in staggered shifts following health and safety guidelines,” explains Wojtalewicz. The band are hoping these songs come together to form their next full-length album, but this is likely to be a little way off. Although they are reluctant to make any broad statements about how any new music will sound, Wojtalewicz makes the bold statement that, “a few of our new demos feel like some of the best songs we’ve ever written,” although swiftly caveats this by noting it might well be ‘recency-bias’ – “but if we didn’t feel that way, then why even do it?”
With an evident attention to detail, Graveyard Club remain a polished act; their songs are carefully constructed and their live performances are beautifully melodic without losing any energy. The same goes for the music industry as a whole, but let’s hope we see them on stage again in the not-too-distant future.
This Hallowe’en, Graveyard Club re-released Cellar Door on limited edition opaque aqua vinyl, which includes their standalone single ‘Ouija.’

Photo: Glossy Onions Photography

